AirDNA is the lower-risk place to start
Both let you explore a market and analyze a specific property, so the usual verdict, “AirDNA for the market, STR Insights for the door,” decides nothing. Neither has published a test of its accuracy against the other.
If an Airbnb virtual assistant will run the research, they need their own approved login, written rules for comparable listings, and you reviewing the inputs. Neither retail plan mentions team seats, and AirDNA's terms prohibit password sharing, so confirm individual access with the vendor first.
If you run the research yourself, AirDNA Market Research is the lower-risk place to start: the annual plan costs $1,300.99 less, covers markets outside the United States, exports to CSV, and has a free plan to try first. STR Insights earns its premium only if its demo improves a real US underwriting decision by more than the difference.
STR Insights and AirDNA side by side
| Decision input | STR Insights | AirDNA |
|---|---|---|
| Published research price | $194.99 monthly, $449.99 quarterly, or $1,599.99 annually | Free plan, or Market Research at $99 monthly or $299 annually |
| Coverage | US only; 1M+ rentals across 12K+ markets, by its own count | Global; 15M+ listings across 120K+ markets, by its own count |
| Before you pay | Scheduled demo; no public free tier or time-limited trial | Permanent free plan: each market's score, revenue, occupancy and daily rate in the market list, one sample market in full, and Rentalizer estimates with nine of their comps; recorded and live demos |
| Exports | Not published; ask in the demo about spreadsheet, PDF and API access | Market Research exports market and property charts to CSV; Rentalizer supports PDF |
| Owner prospecting | Not offered publicly; ask in the demo | Available in the separate, quote-based Property Manager product |
| Team access | Not published; ask in the demo | No retail seats published; its terms prohibit password sharing |
Do not buy either product on an accuracy slogan
STR Insights says its rental metrics come from Airbnb and Vrbo and are checked weekly. AirDNA says it collects public Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com listing data daily and validates its model with reservation data from more than 100,000 partner properties. AirDNA explains more of its method, which helps you check a number; it still can't tell you whether the forecast for your property is right.
A forecast is only as useful as its comparable listings, revenue definition, treatment of blocked nights, and data recency. If the product cannot show those inputs, the number is difficult to defend no matter how precise it looks. On AirDNA's free plan, the estimate for our test pool home rested on fifteen comps, nine of them visible: 3-bedroom units in the resort beside the address, four titled as condos. That is the input to look at before the number.
A fair test before you subscribe for a year
- Name the job. Decide whether you are shortlisting a market, underwriting one property, or building an owner-prospect list. Owner prospecting requires AirDNA Property Manager. The $299 Market Research plan does not include it.
- Prepare identical inputs. Use one market you know, one serious candidate market, one thin or unusual market, and five addresses with the same property type and occupancy assumptions.
- Start reversibly. Run AirDNA Free first. Its market list shows each market's 12-month occupancy and rate, but a market's own page locks its charts and its submarkets' detail, and an estimate shows nine of its comps, so for anything past a first look, pay for one month of Market Research before committing annually.
- Bring the same inputs to the STR Insights demo. Ask the rep to show the selected comparable listings, booked-versus-blocked treatment, revenue definition, data date, exports, and access options.
- Check a property you already know. Compare both outputs with actual booking records where possible. Normalize revenue definitions before judging the result.
- Choose the product whose inputs you can explain. If you cannot inspect the comparable listings or explain why an estimate changed, do not use it to pursue or reject a property.
Define the research handoff after access is approved
Give the assistant a written research request that names the market, property type, comparable-listing rules, required exports, and the decision the work will inform. The assistant can collect the evidence and put both products on the same basis; the operator still approves the comparable set and makes the investment decision.
When the research turns into a list of landlords to approach for rental arbitrage, calling them is a separate job. A cold calling virtual assistant works that list, qualifies each landlord, and books the conversations worth your time.
For rate-setting rather than market research, use the Airbnb pricing tool comparison; it is a different decision.