Guesty vs Hostfully: Hostfully for the published price, Guesty Pro for tighter team access

  • Hostfully if you want the price before a call: Growth is $249 a month at 10 listings with its $99 platform fee, plus 1% of the payments it processes and 0.85% of direct-booking rent, and every account gets a booking site.
  • Guesty Pro if your assistant shouldn't see your revenue: every Hostfully role sees nightly rates, and Guesty Pro sets access area by area. Test its messaging and support first; in my year on Guesty Pro, neither kept up.
  • Neither lets you try the plan you'd buy: Hostfully has no free trial, and Guesty's is Lite, so run the access test in both demos.

The public starting prices are not the same unit

Guesty Lite has a low public starting subscription for one to three listings. Hostfully Growth publishes a per-property starting price, a platform fee, and separate payment and direct-booking percentages. Guesty Pro is quoted; Hostfully Pro publishes a higher starting price and removes the two listed percentage fees.

Neither is cheaper until you run your last twelve months of booking, direct-booking and payment volume through both. Permissions need a separate same-duty test. Guesty Pro assigns Full, Partial, or No access by product area; Lite, the plan in Guesty's free trial, has only Admin and Cleaner. Hostfully starts from four built-in roles. The Hostaway vs Guesty access choice includes a third model on the Hostaway side: user groups with View, Modify, Create, and Delete rights across product areas. To decide Guesty versus Hostfully, configure the same guest, pricing, payment, owner, and administrative duties in both products and reject either one that cannot separate them.

At 20 properties, Hostfully Growth starts at $399 a month, then adds two percentage fees

$15 × 20 properties = $300 base subscription

plus platform fee = $99 a month, or $1,069.20 a year billed annually

plus 1% payment-gateway fee = apply to the vendor-defined payment base

plus 0.85% direct-booking fee = apply to direct-booking value

That is what the Hostfully formula needs before it can be compared with a Guesty Pro proposal. Give both vendors the same property count, online-travel-agency booking value, direct-booking value, payment volume, user count, owner count, add-ons, onboarding, and contract term. Require one twelve-month total and the renewal formula.

Guesty and Hostfully side by side

Decision point Guesty Hostfully
Entry price Lite, for 1 to 3 listings: $9 a listing a month on an annual plan plus 1% of each reservation, $27 on the plain annual plan, or $39 month to month, by its billing page. Confirm add-on charges at checkout. Growth starts at $15 per property per month plus a $99 monthly platform fee, a 1% payment-gateway fee, and a 0.85% direct-booking fee.
Higher tier Pro (4 to 199 listings) and Enterprise (200+) require a quote. Pro starts at $25 per property per month plus the $99 monthly platform fee and removes the listed gateway and direct-booking percentage fees. Enterprise is custom.
Distribution Lite starts from an Airbnb connection and adds Booking.com and Vrbo only after Airbnb listings are imported. Pro advertises 60+ channels. Its channel manager advertises direct connections to Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, and 60+ channels.
Team access On Pro, roles use Full, Partial, or No access by product area, with separate main-account and sub-account rules. Lite has two fixed roles, Admin and Cleaner, and two admins at most. Four built-in roles (Property Manager, Booking Agent, Property Sales Manager, and Associate) have varying permission levels and can't be customized; you choose which properties each user sees.
Direct booking and add-ons Confirm the site, payment, owner, accounting, and add-on scope in the applicable plan or proposal. A direct-booking site is included with an account. Open application programming interface (API) access, Digital Guidebooks, and devices are shown as configurable add-ons; transaction fees vary by plan.

“Starting at” is not a twelve-month total. Ask which reservation and payment values each percentage applies to, and which add-ons are mandatory for your workflow.

Use one cost sheet and one access test

Give both vendors the same listing count, online travel agency (OTA) reservation value, direct-booking value, payment volume, contract term, onboarding scope, and add-ons. Require a twelve-month total at current volume and at the renewal scenario you expect.

  1. Create an agent who can answer guests but cannot view payouts or change payment settings.
  2. Create a revenue user who can change rates only for assigned properties.
  3. Create an owner view that exposes the agreed properties and figures, but no other owner data.
  4. Change one permission and confirm its effect in a test login, including any main-account override.

Run it in Guesty's demo, not its trial. We tried step 1 in Guesty's trial: Lite let us add our assistant only as an Admin, billing included, or as a Cleaner, who can't answer guests. Logged in as that Admin, our assistant reached billing and the account holder's Delete user button.

If Hostfully's built-in roles map cleanly, that part of the decision is simple. They can't be customized, so if they do not, only Guesty's more granular model can pass; make Guesty demonstrate it. Choose only after both the access test and total-cost sheet pass.

What would decide it

Guesty's clearer advantage is granular access by product area, on Pro. Hostfully's clearer advantage is a direct-booking site included with the account and a public per-property starting model. Guesty wins when its proposal prices that finer access competitively. Hostfully wins when its four built-in roles cleanly represent the team and its direct-booking economics produce the lower total. If neither vendor can produce the complete bill or the minimum access boundary before contract, neither has won.

For the wider field, compare these two against the other Airbnb management software candidates using the same reservation and permissions tests.

If the chosen access model is ready to become a recurring role, a trained Airbnb virtual assistant can take it: book a consultation.

Choose a time for a 45-minute call

Open the calendar in a full page
Loading calendar…