Hostaway vs Guesty: Hostaway for a team or owners, Guesty Pro only if its quote beats it

  • My pick: Hostaway, what my rentals run on since I left Guesty Pro after a year, for a team with set roles or owners who get statements.
  • Guesty Pro if its quote comes in lower for the same listings, channels and owner work. Test its messaging and support first; they're what failed me.
  • Neither publishes a price past Guesty Lite's 3 listings. Plans that publish one and carry owner statements cost $165 to $309 a month at 10 listings, so hold both quotes to that.

Hostaway vs Guesty pricing at 10, 25 and 50 listings

Neither puts a price on the page past three listings. Hostaway's pricing is a form that asks how many listings you manage, then a sales call. Guesty sells Lite only for one to three listings and quotes Pro from four. So the number to hold each quote against is what the systems that do publish a price charge for the same owner work: OwnerRez with Property Management, Lodgify Ultimate and Hospitable Mogul, each with owner statements.

Portfolio Hostaway Guesty Published plans with owner statements, a month
10 listings Quote, in its 2 to 14 band Pro, by quote $165 to $309
25 listings Quote, in its 15 to 49 band Pro, by quote $288 to $759
50 listings Quote, in its 50+ band Pro, by quote $461 to $1,509

On top of the subscription, Hostaway charges $500 to onboard you, by its own figure, and lets you pay monthly or save on an annual plan. Its booking engine adds 1.8% to US bookings paid through Stripe, which the guest pays unless you absorb it. Guesty takes no percentage on bookings through its own booking engine and publishes no onboarding fee. Hostaway's comparison page puts Guesty's at $1,500 with a 13-month contract, while Guesty's pricing page offers monthly or annual plans, so get Guesty's fee and term in writing before you compare.

Once both prices are quoted, the proposal becomes the product

“Hostaway for smaller managers, Guesty for larger ones” doesn't hold up. Both cover owner reporting, team permissions, accounting connections and broad distribution, so both need the same Airbnb management software test: list the jobs that must share one system before either one is a finalist.

I've run my own rentals on both. I was on Guesty Pro for a year, and as we grew, support fell short and messaging wasn't reliable, so I moved everything to Hostaway, which took 5 to 7 days. No one wants to switch PMSs, so test the two things that failed me, support and messages, before you sign either contract.

Decide whether an employee or an Airbnb virtual assistant will handle guest messages, rates or owner reports, then build both demos around that person's access.

Give both sales teams the same portfolio file

Portfolio: active listings now, seasonal listings, multi-units, and expected renewal count.

Money: base subscription, booking and payment fees, direct-booking fees, onboarding, migration, and add-ons.

People: administrators, guest service, revenue, finance, owners, cleaners, and least-privilege access.

Contract: term, renewal formula, support tier, data ownership, export, and offboarding.

Hostaway and Guesty side by side

Decision point Hostaway Guesty
Published price None. The pricing form asks whether you have 2 to 14, 15 to 49 or 50+ listings, then goes to a quote. Lite, for 1 to 3 listings, is $9 a listing a month on an annual plan plus 1% of each reservation, or $39 month to month on its billing page. Pro (4 to 199 listings) and Enterprise (200+) are quote-based.
Booking sites Direct two-way connections to Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia and Google, plus additional marketplaces; exact connections vary by channel. Lite starts from Airbnb and adds Booking.com and Vrbo once Airbnb listings are imported. Pro connects Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com and Expedia by API and advertises 60+ channels.
Team access User groups can be limited by listing and by View, Modify, Create, and Delete permissions across product areas. On Pro, roles use Full, Partial, or No access by area, with separate Main HQ and sub-account rules. Lite has Admin and Cleaner only, and a Lite Admin is offered Delete user on the account holder's own login.
Owner workflow Owner statements support drafts, publishing, automation, permissions, and PDF or spreadsheet export. Pro includes an Owners Portal. Accounting views and owner statements depend on the Accounting feature.
What only the quote tells you Subscription, onboarding, payment, direct-booking, and add-on costs; contract term; the exact features included in the quote. The same items for Pro or Enterprise. Lite is the only tier with a complete public starting formula.

“Available” does not mean “included in your proposal.” Ask each vendor to mark every required feature as included, add-on, usage-priced, or unavailable.

Test messages, support, permissions and owner reports

Use the same sample account in both demos: one administrator, one guest-service agent, one revenue manager, and one owner with two properties. Give the test user the same access you plan to assign in production. Do not accept a slide. Ask the salesperson to configure the accounts while you watch.

  1. Let the guest-service agent answer messages but not view payouts or change payment settings.
  2. Let the revenue manager change rates for assigned properties without opening owner financials.
  3. Create a draft owner statement, keep it hidden, publish it, and export the underlying figures.
  4. Change one permission and confirm which account level overrides it.
  5. Ask how the same workflow behaves for a multi-unit property and separate owners.
  6. Have each set up your check-in message as an automation, trigger it on a test reservation, and watch it arrive at the time you set. In Guesty each message goes by one channel, the booking site, SMS or email, so ask for two if you want both.
  7. Get the support hours and channels your plan includes in writing, then send a question on a Saturday evening and time the answer.

The test shows whether each person can see and change only what their role needs, and whether the two things that pushed me off Guesty hold up for you. Watch multi-unit listings on Hostaway: an owner assigned to one sub-unit can see the calendar and reservations for the whole multi-unit listing. If that's your portfolio, settle it in the demo, before you migrate. Neither lets you run the test yourself first: Hostaway has no trial, and Guesty's is Lite, where we built this check-in automation and switched it on, but no reservation can fire it until an Airbnb listing is connected.

For a public-plan baseline against Hostaway, use the Hostaway vs Lodgify comparison.

If the guest-service role is ready to staff, book a consultation and we'll scope it to the permissions you tested.

Choose a time for a 45-minute call

Open the calendar in a full page
Loading calendar…