Hostaway vs Lodgify: Hostaway for a team or owners, Lodgify for your own booking website
- Hostaway, what my rentals run on, if a team works the account or owners get statements: each login held to its listings and sections, statements on a schedule, priced by quote.
- Lodgify if your own website takes bookings, or will: no booking fee on any plan, $231 a month at 10 listings on Professional, and a 7-day trial without a card.
- Tasks, owner statements and permissions need Lodgify Ultimate, $307 a month at 10 listings, so that's the plan to hold against Hostaway's quote.
Use Lodgify's public tiers as the baseline
My rentals run on Hostaway, with my team working in it, and it's the one I'd put first once other people's money or other people's logins are involved. Lodgify earns its price when your own website takes the bookings, and of the two it's the one you can price and try before a sales call.
Both products include an Airbnb channel manager alongside wider operations tools. Lodgify sells messaging, tasks, owner statements, and reporting. Hostaway sells a direct-booking site alongside its channel, owner, team, and accounting tools.
The difference is how you buy them. Lodgify's pricing shows which plan unlocks each workflow; Hostaway asks for your portfolio details and sends a quote. So compare the cheapest Lodgify plan that covers your needs with a Hostaway proposal for the same needs.
If neither product covers the required operating model, return to the wider Airbnb channel manager shortlist without changing the requirement list.
What each Lodgify plan adds
Run the current calculator for the lowest plan containing every required feature and at your property count; do not multiply a one-property promotion. Give Hostaway the same scope and ask it to price every line.
Put Hostaway's proposal beside the viable Lodgify tier
| Requirement | Lodgify | Hostaway |
|---|---|---|
| Direct Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com connections | On every plan. The trial's channel manager offers those three and a calendar feed (iCal) for the rest, with no Expedia to connect. Basic covers one rental and Starter two, so past two listings you're on Professional or Ultimate. | The channel manager advertises direct connections to major booking sites plus additional marketplaces. Confirm every required channel in the quote. |
| A built-in direct-booking website | Starts in Starter, which covers up to two rentals; past that it comes with Professional and Ultimate. | Offered. Each booking through it carries Hostaway's 1.8% booking engine fee on US listings paid through Stripe, charged to the guest unless you absorb it; the site's own price and scope come in the quote. |
| Automated messages and Google Vacation Rentals | Both come with Professional: $231 a month at 10 listings, $421 at 25 and $696 at 50, billed monthly. | Both are advertised within the platform; confirm inclusion, limits, and channel eligibility in the proposal. |
| Tasks plus owner payments, reports, and statements | All come with Ultimate, which also adds permissions management: $307 a month at 10 listings, $574 at 25 and $968 at 50, billed monthly. | Tasks, owner statements and owner portals, priced in the quote. |
| Trial or buying process | Seven-day trial without a credit card, in which guest messages go only to your own email; public monthly and annual plan prices that change with property count. | Sales questionnaire and demo; no public dollar price. |
Make one direct booking travel through the whole system
- Quote a stay on the direct site with the same rate, minimum stay, tax, fee, and cancellation rule used on the booking channels.
- Reserve and pay as a guest; verify the confirmation, calendar, payment record, and scheduled messages.
- Change the dates, then cancel; verify the refund, reopened nights, task changes, and audit trail.
- If you manage for owners, carry that reservation into a statement with one expense and one manual adjustment.
- Export the reservation, payment, guest, and owner records produced by the test.
We ran it in Lodgify's trial on two test rentals. On the pool home the site's quote came out right, $720 for three nights with the $165 cleaning fee, half due at booking. The checkout won't go on without the guest's phone number, though it doesn't mark the field as required, and with no payment gateway connected its last step takes no card: "No payment will be processed until your reservation is confirmed." We entered the test bookings by hand; with no payment gateway a booking waits, tentative, until you record the deposit yourself. On the condo, adding a night kept the old price until we pressed Update, and cancelling reopened the dates and kept the deposit, but a payment reminder still went to the guest after the cancellation. The owner's month came out as a statement you download as a PDF or a spreadsheet. Hostaway shows you the same booking in a sales demo.
Choose the lowest-cost option that passes. A feature mentioned on a marketing page but absent from your plan or quote does not pass.
Inspect the exit before the migration
Export reservations, guest records, property content, messages, owner statements, and automation rules during the trial or demonstration. Ask which records are machine-readable and which arrive only as PDFs. Confirm how every channel is disconnected and what happens to the direct-booking site and payment records at termination. A platform is not fully evaluated until the business can leave it.
For a quote-to-quote purchase, see Hostaway vs Guesty. If the direct-booking workflow is ready to hand off to a short-term rental virtual assistant, book a consultation and we'll scope it to the access and approval limits you tested.