Updated May 2026 · placing VAs into both
Hostaway vs Lodgify: an operator-neutral comparison .
- ✓Compared on what actually matters past 5 listings.
- ✓Written by the team placing VAs into both stacks every week.
- ✓Pick the tool. Hire the VA. Stop being the bottleneck.
OPERATOR-VIEW · NO AFFILIATE BIAS
● PLACING VAs INTO BOTH WEEKLY
[ WHY THIS COMPARISON ] The fork most operators hit at 5-10 listings
Hostaway and Lodgify cover the same channels, with different centers of gravity. One sells you the operations layer. The other sells you the brand layer.
Lodgify's strongest piece is the branded direct-booking site: templates, custom domain, a real CMS bolted onto the booking engine. If you're trying to wean guests off OTA fees and onto your own URL, that's the differentiator. Hostaway has a booking widget, but no built-out CMS. What Hostaway has instead is wider API coverage, deeper owner-statement accounting, and the staff permissioning that starts mattering once you've got 3+ people touching the PMS daily. The table below scores that gap.
[ SIDE BY SIDE ] Where they differ past 5 units
Hostaway and Lodgify, on what operators actually notice.
Hostaway
Best fit: 5–50 units
Lodgify
Best fit: 5–15 units
Pricing model
Quote-based · per-listing tiers
Public · tiered, includes website
Branded direct-booking site
Booking widget; no built-out CMS
Full website builder · templates · custom domain
Channel coverage
Airbnb · VRBO · Booking · direct
Airbnb · VRBO · Booking · direct
API depth (integrations)
Wide, well-documented
Narrower; fewer third-party hooks
Multi-calendar / multi-listing
Strong
Solid up to ~15 units
Owner statements + accounting
Solid
Basic
Staff permissions + roles
Adequate
Lighter
Time to onboard a VA on it
~2 days
~2 days
Real-world support latency
Hours
Hours; heavier emphasis on docs
Hostaway
Best fit: 5–50 units
- Pricing model
- Quote-based · per-listing tiers
- Branded direct-booking site
- Booking widget; no built-out CMS
- Channel coverage
- Airbnb · VRBO · Booking · direct
- API depth (integrations)
- Wide, well-documented
- Multi-calendar / multi-listing
- Strong
- Owner statements + accounting
- Solid
- Staff permissions + roles
- Adequate
- Time to onboard a VA on it
- ~2 days
- Real-world support latency
- Hours
Lodgify
Best fit: 5–15 units
- Pricing model
- Public · tiered, includes website
- Branded direct-booking site
- Full website builder · templates · custom domain
- Channel coverage
- Airbnb · VRBO · Booking · direct
- API depth (integrations)
- Narrower; fewer third-party hooks
- Multi-calendar / multi-listing
- Solid up to ~15 units
- Owner statements + accounting
- Basic
- Staff permissions + roles
- Lighter
- Time to onboard a VA on it
- ~2 days
- Real-world support latency
- Hours; heavier emphasis on docs
Pricing checked May 2026. Lodgify tiers published; Hostaway is quote-based. Lodgify pricing page couldn't be re-pulled this pass (vendor returned 403) and is flagged for next sweep. Real-world support latency reported by operators we've placed VAs with in the last 90 days. Last verified: 2026-05-24.
[ NEXT ] You picked the tool
Neither tool fails because it's bad. It fails when the operator buys it, sets it up, and runs out of 30 hours a week to actually run it.
The inbox, the calendar, the cleaner schedule, the direct-booking funnel: none of that runs itself. Every VA we place is trained on both Hostaway and Lodgify, embedded in your stack in 3-5 days, running the daily ops while you run the portfolio.
[ THE DECISION ] Where each one fits
Choose Hostaway if you want:
- A wide, well-documented API and a deeper integration catalog past the basics
- Owner-statement accounting that survives QuickBooks and a real finance review
- Staff permissions that scale as a 3-10 person team starts touching the PMS daily
- The ops platform you grow into between 5 and 50 listings
- A VA who can be operational on the platform in roughly 2 days
Choose Lodgify if you want:
- A full website builder bolted onto the booking engine: templates, custom domain, real CMS
- Public, tiered pricing that includes the branded direct-booking site in the plan
- To wean guests off OTA fees and onto your own URL as the primary funnel
- A 5-15 listing operation where one person owns both the brand and the bookings
- Documentation-led support, no enterprise sales conversation to get started
[ FAQ ] Questions operators ask about this
Things people ask picking between these two.
[ 01 ] Is Lodgify's website builder really better than Hostaway's direct-booking page? +
Yes, if you actually want a branded site. Lodgify ships a real CMS. Templates, custom domain, pages you can edit. Hostaway has a booking widget you can drop on a site you build elsewhere, but no built-out website tool. If your plan is to push repeat guests to your own URL and away from OTA fees, Lodgify gets you there in a weekend. If you already have a site (or don't care about one), Hostaway's wider integrations matter more.
[ 02 ] I'm at 5 listings. Hostaway or Lodgify? +
Depends on which problem is biting you. If guest messaging, calendar sync, and cleaner coordination are eating your week, Hostaway gives you more rope: wider integrations with Turno, PriceLabs, smart locks. If you're losing 15% to OTA fees and want a real direct-booking site running by next month, Lodgify ships that out of the box. Most operators we place VAs with at 5–15 units go Hostaway when they have more ops pain than brand pain, Lodgify when it's the other way around.
[ 03 ] We're on Lodgify and outgrowing it. Is the move to Hostaway hard? +
Not as hard as people make it sound. The painful part isn't the tool. It's the data migration: listings, past reservations, owner statements, calendar history. Plan a clean cutover at a low-occupancy weekend, run both for 2 weeks in parallel, then kill the old one. Your VA can drive the whole migration. We've placed operators through it 4 or 5 times. The week after cutover is rough; week three you forget Lodgify existed.
[ 04 ] Do your VAs already know Hostaway and Lodgify? +
Yes. Every VA we place runs through training on both before they're placed. Hostaway takes about 2 days to onboard a trained VA onto your specific setup. Lodgify is similar. The thing we don't train for is your property quirks, your owner statements, your cleaner roster. That's the first week on the job. From signed agreement to embedded VA: 3–5 days.
Already picked? Booking July + August 2026
Don't lose the tool to the lack of operator. Place the VA who runs it.
45-minute call. We map your portfolio, your stack, and have a shortlist of trained operators on your desk in 4 days.