Which one is yours
Guesty and Lodgify are both property management systems (PMSs), built for different businesses. Guesty is built for property managers: each owner gets a portal, trust accounting sits behind it, and Pro lists more than 60 booking channels. It's sold by quote, with add-ons on top. Lodgify is built around your own booking website, with Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking.com connected and every plan's price on its calculator.
I ran my own rentals on Guesty Pro for a year. Support and messaging didn't keep up, so I moved everything to Hostaway, and the move took 5 to 7 days. No one wants to switch PMSs. Whichever of these two you pick, test its messaging and its support before a single listing moves.
Choose Guesty if
- Your owners expect to log in any time and see performance, statements and their own stays, in a portal under your brand.
- You hold owners' money and want trust accounting and 1099s in the system you run guests from.
- You sell on more sites than Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking.com. Guesty lists 60+ channels; past its API connections, Lodgify links other sites by calendar feed, which carries booked dates only.
Choose Lodgify if
- The homes are yours, owned or leased, and your own website takes bookings, or will.
- You want the price before a sales call, a 7-day trial without a card, and no contract.
- Your owners are happy with a monthly statement, which Ultimate builds for $307 a month at 10 listings.
No owners, and nearly every booking comes from Airbnb? Then Guesty's owner side and Lodgify's website would both sit idle, and the best Airbnb management software comparison has systems that cost less than Lodgify at 10 and 25 listings.
Guesty vs Lodgify pricing at 10, 25 and 50 listings
Lodgify puts every plan on its calculator. Basic stops at one rental and Starter at two, so from three listings you're choosing between Professional and Ultimate. Guesty publishes a price only for Lite, which it sells for 1 to 3 listings. From four to 199 it sells Pro, and Pro is a quote.
| Plan | 10 listings | 25 listings | 50 listings | What the price covers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lodgify Professional | $231 | $421 | $696 | Booking website with no booking fee, automated messages, a Google Vacation Rentals listing, co-host access, email and phone support |
| Lodgify Ultimate | $307 | $574 | $968 | Adds owner payments, reports and statements, tasks, permissions for each teammate and a guest app |
| Guesty Pro | Quote | Quote | Quote | 60+ channels, an owners portal and revenue management; accounting and the add-ons go in the quote |
| Lodgify Basic and Starter | No | No | No | Basic stops at one rental and Starter at two |
Lodgify's pricing is monthly billing in US dollars, before tax, with no booking fee, no setup fee and free onboarding, and you can cancel any time. Yearly billing costs less; smart locks and damage protection are add-ons. In Guesty's pricing the extras go into the quote: PriceOptimizer, LocksManager, damage protection and Guest Communication Services on any plan, Guesty Pay and advanced websites on Pro, and the accounting that owner statements need. A lower Guesty package waits until the contract ends, so get the quote for the listing count you'll have in a year.
If Guesty quotes per listing, hold it against Lodgify: at 10 listings about $23 a listing on Professional and $31 on Ultimate, at 50 about $14 and $19. Ultimate is the Lodgify plan with owner statements, so it's the fair match for a Guesty quote that includes accounting.
If Hostaway is your third option, it's a quote too, given after a sales call. Hostaway vs Lodgify holds it against Lodgify's public plans, and Hostaway vs Guesty puts the two quotes side by side.
What your owners get
If the homes are yours, none of this applies, and Lodgify's website is the reason to buy it. If you manage for owners, this is the difference to weigh.
Guesty: a portal for every owner
Each owner gets a portal and an app under your brand, where they see performance and statements and book their own stays, and you tick which numbers each owner sees. Statements, 1099s and trust accounting run on Guesty's Accounting feature, which isn't in Pro's list, so ask for it in the quote.
Lodgify: a statement each month or quarter
Lodgify builds each owner's statement from the bookings, fees and expenses already in it, once or on a recurring schedule, and downloads it as a PDF or a spreadsheet. Ours came out as one page: the owner's payout and yours at the top, then each booking with its room rate, fees and split. It's headed with the account holder's own name rather than your business's, and every new owner starts at 100% of the room rate to you until you set the split. Make the owner a user and they see only their own statements; as a Rental Owner they can also see their rental's bookings in Lodgify's mobile app, with guest contact details and payments hidden unless you change that. For trust accounting, Lodgify connects to VRPlatform, which needs a subscription of its own.
Owner statements start on Ultimate
Owner payments and statements sit on Ultimate with tasks and team permissions: $307 a month at 10 listings, $76 more than Professional, and $968 at 50.
Run one owner's month through both
Take one owner with two homes and last month's real numbers. Run it in Lodgify's 7-day trial or its demo, and have Guesty run it live in theirs. Guesty's own free trial can't: it's Lite, which has no owner statements or portal and starts only from a connected Airbnb listing.
The statement: build that owner's month with your management fee, the cleaning fees and one repair bill, and check the payout against your own numbers to the dollar. Ours, a month with one booking and no repair bill, matched to the dollar once we had moved the split from Lodgify's starting 100% to the manager: 80% of $370 in room rate is the owner's $296.
The owner's view: log in as the owner. In Guesty that's their portal; in Lodgify, a user linked to the owner, who should see only their own statements.
The messages: set your check-in message to send on its own, trigger it on a test booking and watch it reach the guest on Airbnb at the time you set. Messaging is what failed me on Guesty Pro. In Guesty's free trial we got as far as building that message and switching it on; firing it needs a connected Airbnb listing.
The quote: get Guesty's price for the listing count you'll have in a year, with accounting, every add-on you'd use, onboarding, support hours and the contract term, and set it beside Lodgify Ultimate at that count.
Pick the one that gets every line right at the lower total. If the homes are yours, the Lodgify review has the direct-booking test to run instead, and the Guesty review lists what its quote should cover.
What your assistant can reach in each
Your assistant's day is the inbox, the calendar and the reservations, and nothing that moves money. In Guesty Pro you give them a role with exactly that; Lite has only Admin and Cleaner, and its Admin is a second owner: from our assistant's Admin login, the account holder's own page offered Delete user. In Lodgify, choosing what a teammate sees starts on Ultimate; on Professional they'd log in with co-host access, so find out in the trial what that login opens. In the trial we gave ours the Member role, which starts with nothing, and four switches: calendar and reservations, guest names, guest contact details and booking source, on one rental. Lodgify keeps the scheduled messages and publishing the website for the account holder alone, and leaves the channel manager out of a teammate's menu, though its address still opened for ours. The reservations switch also offered our assistant The host cancels and refunds all payments.
If you manage for owners, an Airbnb virtual assistant from us can also keep each owner updated and answer their questions. Our property-management assistants train on Guesty before they start and every month after, with the recordings sent to you; on Lodgify, you walk yours through your account when they start. Most placements take 3 to 4 days from the first call, so book a free consultation once you've picked the system.