Who should buy which
Hospitable and Guesty each run your calendar, guest messages and cleaning from one property management system (PMS), and they're sold in opposite ways. Hospitable is built for operators running their own listings, and it publishes every price, down to a free plan. Guesty is built for property managers, with 60+ booking channels, an owners portal and trust accounting, and it quotes every plan from four listings up.
I ran my own rentals on Guesty Pro for a year. Support and messaging are what failed me, and neither shows up in a demo. I moved everything to Hostaway in 5 to 7 days. No one wants to switch PMSs, so I'd rather prove a system on real bookings before paying, and of these two, only Hospitable lets you try the plan you'd buy.
Choose Hospitable if
- You run your own listings, owned or leased, and want messages, pricing and cleans automated without a sales call.
- You want to read the whole bill first, try every feature on your own listings for 14 days without a card, then pay month to month.
- You manage for owners who want statements and a portal, and trust accounting can wait: Mogul has both, $309 a month at 10 listings.
Choose Guesty if
- You sell beyond Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com and Agoda. Guesty connects Expedia directly and lists 60+ channels.
- You hold owners' money in trust and need trust accounting now. Guesty's Accounting has it built in; Hospitable lists it as coming soon.
- You're heading toward 50 listings, where Hospitable Professional reaches $779 a month, and you'll negotiate a quote to beat it.
Past about 20 listings, or managing for owners with a team, look at Hostaway as well. It's what my rentals run on, and Hospitable vs Hostaway lines it up against Hospitable.
Guesty vs Hospitable pricing at 10, 25 and 50 listings
Hospitable's table has every number you need: a base price that includes the first two listings on Professional or three on Mogul, then $15 or $30 for each listing after, a rate that doesn't fall as you grow. Host can't go past two listings, and Essentials is free. Guesty's only printed price is Lite's, for one to three listings; Pro, from four to 199, is a quote.
| Plan | 10 listings | 25 listings | 50 listings | What it covers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hospitable Professional | $179 | $404 | $779 | Dynamic pricing, a direct-booking site, smart lock and thermostat automations, guest payment collection; $59 covers two listings, then $15 each |
| Hospitable Mogul | $309 | $759 | $1,509 | Adds owner statements and portals, and accounting in Hospitable or QuickBooks; $99 covers three listings, then $30 each |
| Hospitable Essentials | $0 | $0 | $0 | Inbox, a limited set of scheduled messages and cleaning tasks; dynamic pricing $15 a listing after its trial, and no outside pricing tool |
| Guesty Pro | Quote | Quote | Quote | 60+ channels, an owners portal and revenue management; PriceOptimizer, LocksManager, Guesty Pay and accounting go in the quote |
| Hospitable Host | No | No | No | Host stops at two listings |
Hospitable's prices are monthly in US dollars, before tax, with no contract and no onboarding fee. Yearly billing takes 12% off but commits you for 12 months. On the paid plans, a listing with pricing switched on and no check-in that month costs $10, each direct booking costs 1% on the Basic direct-booking plan, and smart devices past the two included per listing on Professional are $5 each. Guesty's quote carries its extras: PriceOptimizer, LocksManager, damage protection and Guest Communication Services on any plan, and Guesty Pay and advanced websites on Pro.
What you're signing up for
For most operators, this is what decides it. Hospitable sells a plan you can read, try and leave. Guesty Pro sells a quote you negotiate, with add-ons on top and a contract behind it.
Hospitable: month to month, with pricing in the plan
Every Hospitable plan runs with no contract and no onboarding fee, and the 14-day trial opens every feature without a card. From Host up, dynamic pricing is part of the price for each listing with a check-in that month.
What that pricing shows you
Each night gets a suggested rate with the arithmetic beside it: the base price, then plus or minus for demand, season, lead time and weekday. On Guesty, dynamic pricing is PriceOptimizer, an add-on on every plan.
Guesty: a quote, then a contract
Guesty's free trial is for Lite, which it sells for one to three listings. Pro is sold on a demo and a quote, with PriceOptimizer, LocksManager, Guesty Pay and advanced websites priced on top. Once you've signed, you can move up a package any time; moving down waits until the contract ends.
Hospitable's trial: your listing, beside what you run now
Hospitable's trial runs on Mogul, its top plan, and on a real listing. Add property goes straight to connecting Airbnb, Vrbo or Booking.com, and Hospitable says an Airbnb or Vrbo account already on other software can connect without interfering.
Guesty's trial: Lite, from Airbnb
Guesty's free trial is Lite, not the Pro you'd buy from four listings. It starts from your Airbnb account, asks you to disconnect any other PMS from it first, and keeps the inbox, calendar and tasks locked until the import.
Price next year, then run one real week
Settle the money on paper, then let each one carry real guest messages. Hospitable's trial gives you the product on a listing you connect, all but its dynamic pricing, which you switch on only by subscribing. Guesty's trial is Lite: we built the check-in message there and switched it on, but couldn't fire it without a connected Airbnb listing, so for Guesty, ask for it in the demo.
Next year's count: price Hospitable from its table at the listing count you'll have in 12 months, and ask Guesty to quote the same count.
The same tools: have the quote include PriceOptimizer and LocksManager, and Accounting if you have owners, since Hospitable's plan already covers dynamic pricing and smart locks, and Mogul owner statements.
The term: get Guesty's contract length in writing, with what happens if you drop listings. Hospitable bills month to month.
Support: Hospitable's plan page lists live chat and email 24 hours a day, five days a week, and Guesty's Lite help promises email around the clock. Get what Guesty Pro includes in writing, then send each a question on a Saturday evening and time the answer.
One week of messages: put a real listing on Hospitable's trial and read every message it sends that week. In Guesty's demo, have them build your check-in message and fire it on a test booking. Messaging is where Guesty Pro let me down.
Take Hospitable if the week goes right and it costs less at next year's count. Sign Guesty's contract for a channel or the trust accounting Hospitable can't give you today. The Hospitable review has a fuller trial checklist, and the Guesty review lists what its quote should cover.
Where your assistant fits
Hospitable's logins for teammates are free from Host up; its plan cards and help article on user types leave them off the free plan, though its comparison tables list them there. Give your assistant custom access to the features and properties they cover, and financial data only if they handle payouts; no teammate can see your subscription or invite users, and ours was turned away from both. On Guesty Pro, the role you assign sets those limits; Lite, the plan in Guesty's trial, has only Admin and Cleaner, and from our assistant's Admin login the account holder's own page offered Delete user.
Our property-management assistants train on Guesty before they start and every month after, with the recordings sent to you, and Hospitable is one of the tools they already work in. Most placements take 3 to 4 days from the first call. Once you've chosen, book a free consultation and we'll shortlist an Airbnb virtual assistant for the role.