Same bank, same tax categories, different books
Baselane and Stessa both start free, both open bank accounts at Thread Bank, one per property if you want, and both file each transaction by property under the categories of Schedule E, the IRS form most rental income is reported on. For a landlord with tenants they're close. For an Airbnb operator they part ways at the payout: Airbnb pays you the booking minus its fee, and only Stessa reads what the fee was.
I run my rentals fully remote, with virtual assistants on the team, so I judge a books tool by the routine I'd hand over each month. In Stessa that's one Airbnb file per listing. In Baselane it's a split for every payout, and the payouts grow with every booking.
Choose Baselane if
- Other people spend on your cards. Baselane gives each listing's account its own debit cards with daily or monthly limits, on the free plan.
- Your accountant files from Schedule E and you'd rather not pay for it. Baselane's comes with the free plan; Stessa's comes with Manage, at $15 a month.
- A bookkeeper keeps your books in QuickBooks or Xero. Baselane syncs to both; Stessa is a ledger of its own that exports.
Choose Stessa if
- You keep your own books and won't type Airbnb's fee in. The free plan imports Airbnb's file and records each stay's rent, cleaning fee and Airbnb's fee on separate lines.
- You'll download each listing's Airbnb file every month, or your assistant will, and delete the payouts your bank feed repeats.
- You own some of your rentals and want their value, loans and equity tracked beside the books.
Baselane vs Stessa pricing at 10, 25 and 50 listings
Neither charges by listing, so every plan costs the same at 10, 25 or 50. Both start free. On Stessa you pay for Schedule E; on Baselane, for advanced rules, AI tagging and a login for anyone else. Stessa's own pages disagree on whether a second login needs a paid plan, but its free plan let our assistant in as an Editor.
| Plan | 10 listings | 25 listings | 50 listings | What you get |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baselane Core | $0 | $0 | $0 | Unlimited accounts and debit cards with spend limits, income and expenses by listing, Schedule E and the tax package, QuickBooks and Xero sync |
| Baselane Smart | $20 | $20 | $20 | Sold on an annual plan, $240 a year. Adds AI tagging, rules on a description or amount, receipt matching, balance sheets and logins for a bookkeeper or assistant |
| Stessa Essentials | $0 | $0 | $0 | Unlimited properties, bank feeds, the Airbnb import, income statement and cash flow by property, 5 receipt scans a month |
| Stessa Manage | $15 | $15 | $15 | Or $12 a month billed yearly, $144 a year. Adds the Schedule E report |
| Stessa Pro | $35 | $35 | $35 | Or $28 a month billed yearly, $336 a year. Adds the balance sheet, unlimited receipt scans and a higher rate on Stessa's bank accounts |
Monthly, in US dollars. Baselane's Smart trial runs 30 days and charges the card you give it when the trial ends. Baselane charges nothing to open or keep an account or to send an ACH transfer; same-day ACH is 1%, up to $15, and an outgoing wire $15, free once your balances reach $50,000. Stessa's accounts have no monthly fees, and an outgoing wire costs $5.
The difference that decides: where Airbnb's fee comes from
Airbnb pays you the booking minus its service fee, and it is moving every host to a single fee taken entirely from the payout, 15.5% for most. That fee is a cost of the listing, and the booking before it is what Airbnb's Form 1099-K reports to the IRS. Books built from the bank deposit miss both. Baselane sends a 1099-K of its own only for rent collected through its rent collection tool, so for Airbnb income the form that counts is Airbnb's.
Baselane: one amount per payout
Baselane sees what reaches the bank, one amount per payout. Our sample stay was a $720 booking, and Airbnb kept $111.60; in Baselane it is $608.40 of rent, and the $111.60 never reaches the books, as revenue or as a cost. On the free plan a payout even arrives with no category, and counts as no rent at all until someone files it.
Baselane's fix: a split for every payout
To get the fee in, open each payout and put the booking on one line and Airbnb's fee on a minus line under it, from the listing's earnings in Airbnb. The free plan does it, two amounts and two categories a payout. Rules can't split a transaction, and Baselane refused the sample file Stessa took ("Invalid or missing Amount"); with the payout lines deleted, it took each stay at its payout. So the fee goes in by hand, payout by payout.
Stessa: Airbnb's own file, a line for each part of the stay
Stessa reads the file Airbnb lets you download, with nothing to map. We imported a sample in Airbnb's export format, assigned to our test listing, and each stay came in as the nights, the cleaning fee and Airbnb's fee on lines of their own. What's left is deleting the payouts your bank brings in as well, which Stessa filed as more income without a flag, and checking the tax lines: in our sample, tax passed through by Airbnb came in twice. The importer reads only Airbnb's file; Vrbo and Booking.com stays go in through Stessa's own spreadsheet template.
On the same sample month, Stessa put every stay's fee on a line of its own from Airbnb's file as it downloads. Baselane refused that file, and its books matched Airbnb only after we split each of the three stay payouts by hand, the fee going to Booking & Platform Fees, the category Stessa's import chose for it.
Put one listing's month through both
Use last month for one listing and time each routine. Both run on the free plans, and neither needs your banking moved to try.
The file: in Airbnb, filter your transaction history to that listing and last month, and download the CSV.
Stessa: import the file on Essentials, assigned to the listing, then delete the deposits your bank brought in that the import already covers. We ran a sample of one listing's August: the same six payouts, imported as a bank file, came in as more income with no flag, and one bulk delete took them out.
Baselane: connect the same account and split each of last month's payouts into the booking and Airbnb's fee, from the listing's earnings in Airbnb. We brought the same sample month's six payouts in with Baselane's spreadsheet template, since we connected no bank, and split the three for stays. The Airbnb file Stessa took, Baselane refused.
The check: in both, the month's revenue should equal the listing's gross earnings in Airbnb, and the fees what Airbnb kept. Note how long each took. In our Stessa run, income ($3,466) and fees ($507) matched the file, but the tax Airbnb passed through came in twice, which put the month $196 above what Airbnb paid. In Baselane, after the splits, rent ($3,270) and fees ($507) matched Airbnb to the dollar, and the $196 of tax sat uncategorized until filed.
Multiply each time by your number of listings. If the splits come out lighter, keep the bank and the books in Baselane; if the import does, keep the books in Stessa and add Manage from the month your accountant wants Schedule E.
The Baselane review and the Stessa review go through each plan and screen, and if neither fits, the best rental property accounting software guide covers REI Hub and QuickBooks with a reservation sync.
Give the monthly routine to a bookkeeping assistant
Whichever you keep, the work comes back every month in the same steps. Document once, delegate forever: write the routine down, and your assistant runs it while you read the month's numbers.
On Baselane that takes Smart: invite them as a Bookkeeper or an Assistant with limited access, so they tag transactions and pull reports but can't move money or see card details. On Stessa, confirm your email with the code it sends, then invite them to your portfolio as an Editor: they edit transactions and property details, and can't invite anyone. Have one login do the imports: when our assistant imported a month the owner already had, every line came in twice. Access goes by portfolio, so on the free plan they see every listing.
A bookkeeping virtual assistant we place can be that one login and prepare the monthly handoff, and your accountant keeps the final close. Most placements take 3 to 4 days from the first call. Book a free consultation to scope the role.